Nashville gets a lot of attention for its successes — the cranes dotting the skyline, the big businesses moving to town. But the city is also facing significant challenges. Housing, a good education and a good wage are out of reach for too many Nashvillians. It’s up to those on our 2023 In Charge list to push the city toward a brighter future.
See the In Charge lists for other industries here.
k9C ^m
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mrC2:8 q2C36C —k^DEC@?8m rt~[ #6DE2FC2?E vC@HE9 $6CG:46D {{ri #F?D 4@>A2?J E92E @G6CD66D ~’r92C=6J’D[ hh #6DE2FC2?E U2>Aj !F3 2?5 r@@A U2>Aj #F?] ~?46 <?@H? 2D pq#w[ #v$ :? a_a` D@=5 ':==286 x?? 2?5 q2<6CD $BF2C6]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8ms2C6< q6== —k^DEC@?8m u@F?56C[ r@CD2:C s:DE:==6CJi pDD@4:2E65 H:E9 }2D9G:==6’D 7:CDE >:4C@5:DE:==6CJ[ q6== >@G65 @A6C2E:@? E@ (6586H@@5\w@FDE@? 7C@> |2C2E9@? ':==286 :? a_`d] ~A6?65 C6G2>A65 |2C2E9@? ':==286 DA246 qC6HDE:==6CJ :? a_`h] $4C2AA65 A=2?D 7@C =@42E:@? :? %96 }2E:@?D[ D6==:?8 7@C Sc]a >:==:@?]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mq@3 q6C?DE6:? —k^DEC@?8m ~H?6C[ q@?8@ !C@5F4E:@?Di ~?6 @7 G6E6C2? >6>36CD @7 }2D9G:==6’D 427é D46?6 H:E9 9:D q@?8@ y2G2 427éD 2?5 4@7766] u:5@ 92D 366? 2 w:==D3@C@ ':==286 >2:?DE2J D:?46 `hhe] r@?5F4ED C@2DE:?8 @A6C2E:@?D 2E p==@J 2E %649 w:==]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m}:4< q:D9@A $C] 2?5 }:4< q:D9@A yC] —k^DEC@?8m r@\@H?6CD[ w2EE:6 q’Di u2E96C 2?5 D@? 7@F?565 9@E\49:4<6? C6DE2FC2?E :? a_`a[ :? |:5E@H?[ 2?5 92G6 D:?46 @A6?65 =@42E:@?D :? pE=2?E2 2?5 {2D '682D] t2E6CJ @776CD =@42E:@?D @? t:89E9 pG6?F6 $@FE9[ r92C=@EE6[ u:7E9 Z qC@25H2J 2?5 E96 @C:8:?2= |:5E@H? DA@E]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m|2EE q@5?2C —k^DEC@?8m !2CE?6C[ uC6D9 w@DA:E2=:EJ 2?5 uC6D9 r2A:E2=i !2CE @7 8C@FA 369:?5 %2K:<:’D 2?5 wF89\q23J’D[ 2>@?8 @E96CD] z?@H? 7@C C62= 6DE2E6 9@=5:?8D[ 4@>A2?J @H?D wF?E6CD $E2E:@? 7@@5 92== :? t2DE }2D9G:==6]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m$62? qC@4< —k^DEC@?8m #6DE2FC2E6FCi %96 7@C>6C wFD< 4967^A2CE?6C H2=<65 2H2J 7C@> 9:D r92C=6DE@? AC@A6CE:6D E@ 7@4FD @? 2 D6C:6D @7 t2DE }2D9G:==6 AC@;64ED[ :?4=F5:?8 #65 q:C5 2?5 pF5C6J] p=D@ @A6C2E6D y@J=2?5 @? E96 62DE D:56 2?5 %96 r@?E:?6?E2= :? E96 vC2?5 wJ2EE }2D9G:==6] ~A6?65 pF5C6J :? a_a` 2?5 yF?6 :? a_aa[ 3@E9 :? |4u6CC:? !2C<]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mv:??2 (:?7C66 qFCC6== —k^DEC@?8m p=4@9@=:4 q6G6C286 {2H $64E:@? {6256C[ vF==6EE $2?7@C5 #@3:?D@? U2>Aj |2CE:?i u@C>6C 2DD:DE2?E 5:C64E@C 2?5 :?E6C:> 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 E96 %6??6DD66 p=4@9@=:4 q6G6C286 r@>>:DD:@? ;@:?65 5@H?E@H? =2H 7:C> :? a_`e E@ 96=A =625 H@C< @? =:46?D:?8 2?5 C68F=2E:@? 7@C 9@DA:E2=:EJ 4=:6?ED 2?5 >2?F724EFC6CD[ :>A@CE6CD 2?5 H9@=6D2=6CD]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m|2?66E r92F92? —k^DEC@?8m !C6D:56?E[ |@CA9 w@DA:E2=:EJ vC@FAi u@@5 }6EH@C< 7:IEFC6 @A6?65 r92F92? p=6 U2>Aj |2D2=2 :? a_`c[ E96? 2 D6C:6D @7 9:89\AC@7:=6 DF446DD6Di |2?EC2 pCE:D2? qC6H6CJ[ %à?DFŏ 2?5 %96 |@4<:?83:C5] r=@D65 r922E23=6 :? pF8FDE a_aa 2D D@>6 6>A=@J66D D@F89E F?:@?]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m(:== r966< xxx —k^DEC@?8m !2CE?6C[ p52>D 2?5 #66D6i {625D =2H 7:C>’D 2=4@9@=:4 36G6C286 E62> 2?5 AC@G:56D =:46?D:?8 2?5 C68F=2E@CJ 4@>A=:2?46 25G:46 E@ C6DE2FC2?ED[ 9@E6=D[ 2CE G6?F6D[ 32CD 2?5 4=F3D] v@\E@ D@FC46 7@C %6??6DD66 =:BF@C =2H] (:76 $92C@? r966< @G6CD66D DE2E6’D 3C6H6C’D 2DD@4:2E:@?]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m$92C@? r966< —k^DEC@?8m tI64FE:G6 s:C64E@C[ %6??6DD66 rC27E qC6H6C’D vF:=5i w2D @G6CD66? DE2E6H:56 @C82?:K2E:@? D:?46 =2E6 a_`h] p??@F?465 :? 62C=J a_ab 2=6 EC2:= AC@8C2>]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m$2?5J r@49C2? —k^DEC@?8m !C6D:56?E 2?5 rt~[ rC24<6C q2CC6= ~=5 r@F?ECJ $E@C6i tI\q@@<D\p\|:==:@? rt~ 2?5 '2?56C3:=E 8C25F2E6 @G6CD66D C6DE2FC2?E 4@>A2?J H:E9 23@FE fb[___ 6>A=@J66D]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mp]z] s6EEH:==6C —k^DEC@?8m !C6D:56?E[ st% s:DEC:3FE:?8i ~G6CD66D 2=4@9@=:4 36G6C286 5:DEC:3FE:@? 4@>A2?J 7@F?565 3J E96 s6EEH:==6C 72>:=J :? `hd`]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m|:8?@? uC2?4@:D —k^DEC@?8m u@F?56C 2?5 rt~[ %96 rFA42<6 r@==64E:@?i t?EC6AC6?6FC =2F?4965 32<6CJ 3FD:?6DD :? v6C>2?E@H? :? a__g 2?5 ?@H @A6C2E6D 2? @FEA@DE :? 96C ?2E:G6 }6H ~C=62?D]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mq6?;2>:? v@=536C8 2?5 |2I v@=536C8 —k^DEC@?8m ~H?6CD[ $EC2E68:4 w@DA:E2=:EJi qF:=56CD @7 64=64E:4 C6DE2FC2?E 4@==64E:@? E92E :?4=F56D |6C492?ED[ !:?6H@@5 $@4:2=[ q2DE:@?[ w6?C:6EE2 #65 2?5 r2E3:C5 $62E]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mr=:?E vC2J[ s6CC:4< |@@C6 2?5 t>2?F6= “t]y]” #665 —k^DEC@?8m ~H?6CD[ $=:> U2>Aj wFD<J’D !:KK2 q66C:2i %C:@ 92D 8C@H? A:KK2 2?5 366C W2?5 4:??2>@? C@==X 6>A:C6 36J@?5 }@CE9 }2D9G:==6 E@ =@42E:@?D :? p?E:@49[ pE=2?E2 2?5 $24C2>6?E@] q:C>:?892> :D ?@H E2C86E65] u@C>6C %$& 4=2DD>2E6D E62> H:E9 v6>22= !C2EED E@ @A6C2E6 t v U2>Aj |4 @? y6776CD@? $EC66E]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mw@H2C5 vC66?DE@?6 —k^DEC@?8m #6DE2FC2E6FC 2?5 r@\u@F?56C[ #65 !633=6D w@DA:E2=:EJi }6H *@C< G6E6C2? @H?D @C :D A2CE?6C :? H6==\<?@H? C6DE2FC2?ED DF49 2D c_c z:E496?[ p56=6’D[ q2;@ $6IE@[ t>>J $BF2C65 2?5 $25:6’D]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m{:?FD w2==k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m ~H?6C[ *2K@@ qC6H:?8i ~A6C2E6D G6?6C23=6 3C6H6CJ @G6C=@@<:?8 rF>36C=2?5 #:G6C :? |25:D@?[ 27E6C AC6G:@FD DE@AD 2E |2C2E9@? ':==286 2?5 %96 vF=49] {@H\<6J A6CD@?2 =6?E :ED6=7 E@ 96=A:?8 9:> =625 492C86 :? 492?8:?8 DE2E6’D 366C E2I DECF4EFC6]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mr@C5:2 w2CC:?8E@?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m rt~[ %96 q2<6CJ r@D]i u@C>6C |4s@?2=5’D 7C2?49:D66 =2F?4965 32<:?8 3FD:?6DD :? `hhe[ 255:?8 >F=E:A=6 A=2?ED 2?5 =:?6D @7 3FD:?6DD E@ 3F:=5 d__\6>A=@J66 4@>A2?J]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mw2= w@=56?\q2496k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m tI64FE:G6 r967 2?5 r@\~H?6C[ {@4<6=2?5 %23=6i ~A6?65 t2DE }2D9G:==6 >2:?DE2J H:E9 r2C2 vC292> :? a_`a 27E6C DE:?E H:E9 E96 vC66?3C:6C #6D@CE 4F=:?2CJ 2AAC6?E:46D9:A AC@8C2> 2?5 DE@AD 2E }:4< U2>Aj #F5J’D[ E96 r2A:E@= vC:==6 2?5 t2DE=2?5 r27é]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8ms@F8 w@8C676k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m !2CE?6C[ c%@A w@DA:E2=:EJi %62>D H:E9 !2F= $49C2><@HD<:[ s2G:5 r@?? 2?5 q6? qC@4< E@ @A6C2E6 23@FE a_ C6DE2FC2?ED :? wF?EDG:==6[ |6>A9:D 2?5 y24<D@?[ |:DD:DD:AA:] }2D9G:==6 7:IEFC6D :?4=F56 p>6C:8@[ tE49[ tE4] 2?5 r92C]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mr9C:D wJ?5>2?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m ~H?6C[ |$EC66Ei (:E9 y:> r256?[ 96=A65 EC2?D7@C> |4v2G@4< $EC66E W2<2 |$EC66EX :? %96 vF=49 H:E9 ':C28@[ |@E@[ $2:?E p?6;@ 2?5 z2J?6 !C:>6 W2D H6== 2D |:5E@H?’D %2G6C?X] qF:=5:?8 9@>6 E@ 9:D D:?46\4=@D65 (9:D<6J z:E496? :D D=2E65 E@ 36 C6A=2465 3J DECF4EFC6 E@ 244@>>@52E6 2 wJ2EE r2AE:@? 9@E6=]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m(6D=6J z6682?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m u@F?56C 2?5 rt~[ %2:=v2E6 qC6H6CJi w2D 3F:=E @?6 @7 DE2E6’D 7:G6 =2C86DE 3C6H:?8 @A6C2E:@?D] (6DE s2G:5D@? r@F?EJ 3C6H6CJ 762EFC6D 2=H2JD\3FDE=:?8 E2AC@@> WH:E9 DE6==2C A:KK2X[ 4@>A=6>6?E65 3J 3@FE:BF6 @A6C2E:@?D :? |FD:4 #@H[ }@CE9 r2A:E@= 2?5 t2DE }2D9G:==6]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m}65 {J6C=Jk^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m rt~[ rzt #6DE2FC2?EDi !C6G:@FD=J E96 =6256C @7 E96 :?E6C?2E:@?2= @A6C2E:@?D @7 E96 uC2?<=:?\32D65 A2C6?E @7 w2C566’D 2?5 r2C=’D yC] $A6?5D D@>6 E:>6 :? r2=:7@C?:2[ :? H9:49 rzt H2D 7@F?565 :? `hde]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mp?5J |2CD92==k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m ~H?6C[ p] |2CD92== w@DA:E2=:EJi #F?D uC2?<=:? 4@>A2?J <?@H? 7@C !F4<6EE’D vC@46CJ 2?5 #6DE2FC2?E[ s624@?’D }6H $@FE9[ $4@FE’D !F3 2?5 p>6C:42?2 %2A9@FD6]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m!2E |2CE:?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m ~H?6C[ |2CE:?’D q2C\q\"F6 y@:?Ei %C2?D7@C>65 2 DEC:A\>2==\=@42E65 32C364F6 ;@:?E :? }@=6?DG:==6 :?E@ 2 C6DA64E65 4@>A2?J H:E9 =@42E:@?D :? }2D9G:==6[ {@F:DG:==6[ q:C>:?892> 2?5 r92C=6DE@?] p=D@ @H?D wF89 q23J’D 492:? @7 3FC86C D9@AD]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m|2C8@E |4r@C>24<k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m r967\~H?6C[ |2C8@Ei w6C t2DE }2D9G:==6 C6DE2FC2?E :? u:G6 !@:?ED H2D 2 EC2:=3=2K6C E92E[ :? A2CE[ DAFCC65 }2D9G:==6’D 4FCC6?E 2?5 C@3FDE 4F=:?2CJ D46?6] p C68F=2C y2>6D q62C5 ?@>:?66]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mp?5J |F>>2k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m u@F?56C[ q2C:DE2 !2C=@Ci w:D 427é 6>A:C6 :?4=F56D >F=E:A=6 FC32? =@42E:@?D] p=D@ @H?D C@3@E\E96>65 E:<: 32C r9@AA6C @? 62DE D:56]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mr92C=:6 }6=D@?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m !C6D:56?E 2?5 rt~[ }6=D@?’D vC66?3C:6C s:DE:==6CJi %62>65 H:E9 3C@E96C[ 2?5 9625 5:DE:==6C^4@\@H?6C p?5J }6=D@?[ E@ WC6X=2F?49 =2DE 564256 2 72>:=J 3FD:?6DD E96:C 8C62E\8C62E\8C62E 8C2?572E96C 925 8C@H? :?E@ 2 8=@32= 3C2?5 :? =2E6 `g__D]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mr2E96C:?6 }6H>2? 2?5 (:== }6H>2?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m ~H?6CD[ t5=6J’D q2C\q\"F6 2?5 `a$@FE9 u:==:?8 $E2E:@?i (:76\2?5\9FD32?5 E62> 92D 56=:36C2E6=J 8C@H? t5=6J’D E@ :?4=F56 =@42E:@?D :? r92EE2?@@82[ $J=G2? !2C<[ t2DE }2D9G:==6[ v=6? r2C3@?[ {6?@I ':==286 2?5 s@?6=D@?] !=2??:?8 E@ @A6? :? (:==:2>D@? r@F?EJ’D u24E@CJ 2E uC2?<=:? 2?5 q6CCJ u2C>D] p=D@ @A6C2E6 !2?49@ U2>Aj {67EJVD r2?E:?2]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8ms63 !2BF6EE6k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m tI64FE:G6 r967 @7 tE49[ tE4] 2?5 y2DA6C’Di {@42= C6DE2FC2?E D46?6 >2:?DE2J 7@C >@C6 E92? b` J62CD] w6C >6?FD 2E tE49 :? $@qC@ 2?5 tE4] :? vC66? w:==D 2C6 3F:=E @? 8=@32= 7=2G@CD 2?5 2>@?8 4:EJ’D >@DE 4C62E:G6] %62>65 H:E9 c%@A A2CE?6CD :? a_a_ E@ 4@?G6CE (6DE t?5’D $2=E:?6 E@ y2DA6C’D]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m|2C< !2C<6Jk^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m rt~[ y] p=6I2?56C’Di %@@< E96 96=> @7 FAD42=6 492:? 7C@> {@??:6 $E@FE :? a_`h] }:I65 A@DD:3=6 D2=6 :? a_a_ 2?5 4FE @G6C9625 5F6 E@ E96 r~'xs A2?56>:4] w2D 366? H:E9 4@>A2?J D:?46 `hhb 2?5 925 366? ru~ 367@C6 36:?8 AC@>@E65]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mpFDE:? #2Jk^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m !C6D:56?E 2?5 u@F?56C[ p]#2J w@DA:E2=:EJi ~A6C2E@C @7 |]{]#@D6 ?6:893@C9@@5 AF3D :? |6=C@D6[ $J=G2? !2C<[ |E] yF=:6E 2?5 r2A:E@= ':6H] p=D@ @H?D '@? t=C@5’D 24C@DD 7C@> u:CDE w@C:K@? !2C< 2?5 |6=C@D6 q:==:2C5D :? |6=C@D6] r=@D65 #2>3=6C 2?5 %96 $FE=6C :? |2C49 a_aa]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m#2?5J #2J3FC?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m ~H?6C[ |:5E@H? r276i rF=:?2CJ 2CED AC@8C2> 2E }2D9G:==6 $E2E6 r@>>F?:EJ r@==686 :D ?2>65 :? 9:D 9@?@C] w:D |FD:4 r:EJ w@DA:E2=:EJ r@?DF=E:?8 :D A2CE @7 A2CE?6CD9:A E92E @A6?65 |@IJ w@E6= ?62C r232?2 %2AD 2?5 56G6=@A65 4@?46AE A=2? 2?5 >6?F 7@C C6:?G6?E65 t==:DE@? !=246 $@52 $9@A]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mq2:=6J $A2F=5:?8k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m r@\~H?6C[ y24<2=@A6 qC6H:?8i p 7@C>6C '2?56C3:=E {2H 8C25F2E6 H9@ D96=G65 =682= 42C66C 7@C 3C6H:?8 :?5FDECJ H@C<[ $A2F=5:?8 E62>D H:E9 4@\@H?6C $E6G6 (C:89E E@ CF? @?6 @7 }2D9G:==6’D >@DE 36=@G65 3C6H6C:6D] sF@ 6IA2?565 :? a_`g E@ #2?49 4@>A=6I :? (6586H@@5\w@FDE@? E96? 4=@D65 vF=49 =@42E:@? :? a_a_]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mr9C:DE:2? $A62CDk^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m u@F?56C 2?5 !C6D:56?E[ %6??6DD66 qC6H (@C<Di ~A6C2E6D A@AF=2C !:6 %@H? 3C6H6CJ <?@H? 2=>@DE 2D >F49 7@C :ED :?G6?E:G6 >6?F 2?5 5:DE:?4E:G6 :?5@@C 2?5 @FE5@@C DA246D 2D :ED BF2=:EJ 2=6D]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8my:>>J $AC25=6Jk^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m rt~[ $E2?52C5 uF?4E:@?2= u@@5D vC@FAi (2D ae H96? 72>:=J 3@F89E $E2?52C5 r2?5J :? `hga] qFD:?6DD 8C6H E@ d__\A=FD 6>A=@J66D 367@C6 $AC25=6J D@=5 :E :? a_`f E@ C67@4FD @? v@@ v@@ r=FDE6CD] $@qC@ D9@A C6@A6?65 :? =2E6 a_a` 27E6C 36:?8 4=@D65 7@C Sa >:==:@? FA52E6]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8mz6?E %2J=@Ck^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m r@\u@F?56C[ q=24<DE@?6 qC6H:?8i p? 244@F?E2?E H9@ D6CG6D 2D E96 56 724E@ 8@572E96C @7 4:EJ’D 366C D46?6] ~A6?65 q=24<DE@?6 :? `hhc] }@H 42??:?8 366CD E@ DFAA=6>6?E E9@D6 E96 3C6H6CJ DE:== 3@EE=6D] qC6HD =286CD 7@C $4@EE |6CE:6’D }2D9G:==6 qC6H:?8 r@>A2?J]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m"\yF2? %2J=@Ck^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m ~A6C2E:?8 !2CE?6C[ #665 w@DA:E2=:EJi !2CE?6CD H:E9 t5 #665 2?5 $2> #665 E@ @G6CD66 4@>A2?J <?@H? 7@C $:?6>2 2?5 gE9 U2>Aj #@2DE]k^Am
kA 4=2DDlQx?r92C86q@5JQmkDEC@?8m%2?5J (:=D@?k^DEC@?8m kDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\D:K6i ``]_AEj =:?6\96:89Ei `_fTj 7@?E\72>:=Ji Vr2=:3C:V[D2?D\D6C:7j >D@\2D4::\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\72C62DE\7@?E\72>:=Ji r2=:3C:j >D@\72C62DE\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\92?D:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\=2E:?j >D@\3:5:\7@?E\72>:=Ji V%:>6D }6H #@>2?Vj >D@\3:5:\E96>6\7@?Ei >:?@C\3:5:j >D@\2?D:\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\72C62DE\=2?8F286i t}\&$j >D@\3:5:\=2?8F286i p#\$pjQm—k^DA2?m r967\~H?6C[ r:EJ w@FD6i #2?<D 2>@?8 }2D9G:==6’D >@DE 564@C2E65 4967D[ H:??:?8 AC6DE:8:@FD y2>6D q62C5 pH2C5 2D q6DE r967 :? E96 $@FE962DE :? a_`e] w:D r:EJ w@FD6 :? v6C>2?E@H? 92D C6>2:?65 2 }2D9G:==6 DE2A=6 D:?46 @A6?:?8 :? a__f]k^Am
